AbstractThis study aims to demonstrate a novel technique for dural suturing using a uniportal endoscopic approach in spinal surgery. Although this procedure presents inherent challenges due to the limited working space and visibility, it can be optimized by using specialized endoscopic instruments to ensure precision and efficiency. This technique enables the immediate repair of unintended dural injuries through the same endoscopic route, without the need to convert to open surgery. Therefore, it offers a minimally invasive solution for dural repair, reducing patient recovery time and minimizing surgical risks.
The objective of this article is to demonstrate a novel technique for dural repair via a uniportal endoscopic approach in a clinical case of L3–4 stenosis. This case involved an elderly patient with severe lumbar stenosis, operated on using an interlaminar endoscopic system (Maxmore, Maxmore spine, Germany) under general anesthesia.
A 76-year-old patient with L3–4 stenosis was operated on under general anesthesia in the prone position, supported on pads for optimal exposure. An interlaminar endoscopic approach (Maxmore system) was used to treat the stenosis. During the procedure, a dural tear occurred, requiring immediate repair. The technique involved the use of Prolene 6.0 sutures, passed through the dura’s margins with the assistance of delicate instruments, and completed through the endoscopic system without conversion to open surgery. The video demonstration illustrates the step-by-step approach, highlighting the effectiveness of this minimally invasive technique.
In recent years, the advent of endoscopic spinal surgery has brought numerous advancements in minimally invasive techniques, particularly for managing degenerative conditions of the lumbar spine.
We believe that a delicate technique, primarily utilizing high-performance drilling with an interchange of cutting and diamond burrs, combined with continuous saline irrigation to ensure optimal visualization of anatomical structures, is essential for safe decompression. Additionally, meticulous dissection of the ligamentum flavum and dural sac is crucial in preventing unintended dural injuries. Ultimately, prevention through meticulous surgical technique should remain the primary objective in lumbar stenosis surgeries to minimize complications and enhance patient outcomes.
However, with these advancements comes the challenge of dealing with dural tears, a common complication during such procedures. Repairing dural tears via endoscopy remains a relatively new and evolving concept, with various approaches being explored by different authors, each offering distinct solutions to this complex problem.
Müller et al. [1] undertook a comprehensive review of the literature to examine the management of dural tears in endoscopic lumbar spinal surgery. Their findings highlighted that the incidence of dural tears is notably higher in endoscopic procedures compared to traditional open surgeries, especially in cases involving lumbar stenosis. This complication presents a significant challenge, particularly as the limited working space in endoscopy makes primary closure via suturing technically demanding. Müller et al. [1] emphasized that there is no consensus on the ideal technique for endoscopic dural repair, but they noted that the use of autologous muscle or fat grafts in combination with fibrin glue or collagen sponges appears to be a safe and effective method. These materials create a seal over the dural defect, allowing for cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) containment without the need for open conversion [1].
Building on this, Shin et al. [2] introduced a novel solution through their development of a full-endoscopic dural suture repair technique, known as Youn's technique. Unlike traditional approaches, which often require conversion to open surgery to achieve direct repair under microscopic visualization, this method allows for direct suturing of the dura using an endoscopic approach. The authors acknowledged that the need to convert to open surgery can be particularly problematic when patients are under local anesthesia, as is common in many endoscopic procedures. By avoiding this conversion, Youn's technique provides a minimally invasive alternative, offering a promising approach to maintaining the benefits of endoscopy while managing dural tears effectively.
Further expanding on the theme of endoscopic dural repair, Zhao et al. [3] presented the case of a patient with a dural injury and cauda equina herniation during percutaneous endoscopic lumbar discectomy. Their innovative approach involved the use of a double-line suture technique, performed entirely through the endoscope. The procedure successfully prevented CSF leakage and maintained dural integrity, with no complications observed during a one-year follow-up period. This case report underscores the potential for endoscopic techniques to evolve beyond the limitations of nonsuturing methods and demonstrates that, with the right techniques, full repair of dural tears is achievable without abandoning the endoscopic approach [3].
A different approach is highlighted by Pruttikul et al. [4], who addressed the challenges of dural closure following interlaminar endoscopic lumbar surgery. Instead of focusing on suturing, the authors proposed a technique using autologous fat grafts combined with Gelfoam to seal the dural tear. This method proved highly effective, with no reported cases of CSF leakage or wound complications in their series. The simplicity and reliability of this approach make it an attractive option, especially in cases where suturing is not feasible due to anatomical or technical constraints [4].
Finally, Bergamaschi et al. [5] contributed to the evolving landscape of endoscopic dural repair by describing a full-endoscopic transforaminal approach for treating dural injuries. Their report demonstrated that primary dural repair could be successfully performed using an endoscope, offering an alternative to the widely accepted practice of converting to open surgery. This technique not only represents a significant advancement in the management of one of the most common complications in spinal surgery, but it also broadens the possibilities for treating such injuries in a minimally invasive manner. By proving that suturing via endoscopy is feasible, Bergamaschi et al. [5] have paved the way for further innovations in endoscopic spine surgery.
In conclusion, dural tears are a relatively common complication in lumbar spine surgery, but there is still no standardized approach for suturing these tears endoscopically. The concept of endoscopic dural suturing is relatively new, and various authors have proposed different solutions for managing this complex issue. Some favor direct suturing techniques, such as Youn's method and the double-line suture, while others advocate for nonsuturing alternatives like the use of autologous grafts and sealing materials. These varied approaches highlight the ongoing evolution of endoscopic techniques, reflecting both the challenges and opportunities in this field. With advancements in instrumentation and increased training, endoscopic dural repair could become a more viable and effective solution, reducing the need for surgical conversion and improving patient outcomes. However, further research and consensus are needed to optimize the management of dural tears in minimally invasive spine surgery.
WRITTEN TRANSCRIPT0:07 Case PresentationPatient presented with complaints of neurogenic claudication, with significant stenosis at the L3–4 segment. The procedure was performed with the patient in the prone position on cushions, using a left paramedian posterior interlaminar approach.
0:25 Surgical Exposure of the L3–4 SegmentAfter bone removal using a drill and Kerrison rongeur, the ligamentum flavum was exposed.
0:34 Ligamentum Flavum ExposureThe ligamentum flavum was observed after the removal of the laminae and the bony portion of the L3 spinous process, undercutting the spinous process.
0:45 Ligamentum Flavum DissectionThe ligamentum flavum appeared to be extremely thickened with clear adhesions to the dural sac.
0:56 Dural TearDuring the removal of the ligamentum flavum, a large unintentional dural tear was observed.
1:04 Dural Sac DissectionAfter achieving hemostasis, we were able to better observe the exit of numerous nerve roots through the dural defect. A large number of nerve roots could be observed. This overlap of roots presents technical challenges, as they are at risk of adhering to surrounding muscular structures and developing early fibrosis due to the scarring process. The proximity of the nerve roots to the exposed area requires careful handling to avoid these complications. Meticulous exploration of the dura mater’s edges was performed to allow for accurate suturing, minimizing potential issues such as nerve root adhesion or fibrosis.
1:41 Dural SutureWe extended the exposure of the dura mater to gain control of its edges in preparation for suturing the dura. For a suture to be performed using a uniportal endoscopic approach, a fine 6.0 Prolene suture with a small needle is required. The instruments used included a delicate disc forceps, allowing for careful manipulation of the needle during the procedure. Using a 6.0 Prolene suture with a short needle and a fine disc forceps, we passed the suture individually through each edge of the dura mater. The knot was tied outside the working cannula and then lowered into place with the aid of the forceps.
2:36 Protecting the Nerve RootsGreat care was taken to isolate the nerve roots during the suturing process, ensuring that all roots remained inside the dural sac and avoiding any accidental suturing of the nerve roots by the needle.
NOTESREFERENCES1. Müller SJ, Burkhardt BW, Oertel JM. Management of dural tears in endoscopic lumbar spinal surgery: a review of the literature. World Neurosurg 2018;119:494–9.
2. Shin JK, Youn MS, Seong YJ, Goh TS, Lee JS. Iatrogenic dural tear in endoscopic lumbar spinal surgery: full endoscopic dural suture repair (Youn’s technique). Eur Spine J 2018;27(Suppl 3):544–8.
3. Zhao R, Li N, Zhang J, Luo X, Zhang X. Endoscopic double line suture repair technique for repairing Iatrogenic dural tear: a technical case report. Eur Spine J 2024;33:4397–403.
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||